Mitnick's Malice, Shimomura's Chivalry

Three books on the celebrated hacker case debunk one another's myths

Dec 30, 1995 |

I. T h e T w o P i c t u r e s

Thick glasses, double chin, frowning lips and a bitter stare: Kevin Mitnick's 1989 mugshot is forbidding -- a hacker gargoyle. By the time of Mitnick's most recent arrest, in February, 1995, the photo had appeared twice on the front page of the New York Times. No one made Mitnick into a hacker; that was his own choice and responsibility. But the media turned his trespasses into legend. The Times turned that little photo into a receptacle for all its readers' projections of digital-age paranoia -- an icon of junk-food-fed, anti-social computer thievery.

Who might exorcize this demon? How about a young, Japanese-born physicist, ski bum and computer-security expert, revealed in photos as an elfin young man with long black hair -- in short, a wizard like Tsutomu Shimomura? When Mitnick apparently broke into Shimomura's computer system on Christmas Day, 1994, he threw down a challenge that would lead to his capture two months later. If Mitnick was "the dark-side hacker" (as he's called in "Cyberpunk," until recently his only in-depth portrait), then his nemesis, Shimomura, stepped right out of central casting into the role of a Jedi knight. The story of the Mitnick manhunt, recounted by veteran computer reporter and "Cyberpunk" co-author John Markoff, broke in the New York Times on February 16, 1995 -- setting off a different kind of chase, one involving agents and deals and contracts. This month, the stores will be crowded with the fruits of that second hunt -- a complementary trio of books, each, "Rashomon"-like, providing a different angle of vision on the Mitnick saga. Individually, these volumes are dissatisfyingly incomplete. Put them together, though, and they debunk the very media-legend stereotypes that sold each of the authors' contracts. Mitnick is no demon; Shimomura is no wizard. Crime and punishment online is a lot harder to score than a Dungeons-and-Dragons-style duel.

Recent Stories

Ask the pilot
Seat ploppers, tray slammers, lousy airport terminal design and other pet peeves. Plus: Will U.S. airlines hit Cuban tarmac thanks to Obama?
Ask the pilot
Propped up by a culture of fear, TSA has become a bureaucracy with too much power and little accountability. Where will the lunacy stop?
Ask the pilot
Flying isn't much fun, but for now people keep doing it anyway. What can the airlines do to keep their customers happy?
Slick John McCain and the offshore oil ruse
The safety and economics of offshore drilling are distractions from the much larger challenges that humanity faces: Climate change and peak oil.
Ask the pilot
The smell of smoke in the cockpit, and it's back to Boston for a planeload of fixated Japanese tourists.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!