Altman's work with actresses is often in that league; in fact, there may never have been another director who has given us such a rich panorama of female performances, or who has delighted in such a wide range of physical and emotional female types. They range from the hard-bitten yet vulnerable examples of Julie Christie (in "McCabe") and Susannah York (in "Images") to the high-strung, self-dramatizingly serious women (Blakley in "Nashville" and Sally Kellerman in "MASH"), all forehead and cheekbones, for whom Faye Dunaway might have been a template, to the long-faced, down-to-earth women like Louise Fletcher (in "Thieves Like Us") and Lily Tomlin to the one-of-a-kind Shelley Duvall (in "McCabe," "Three Women" and "Popeye").
From Sandy Dennis in "That Cold Day in the Park" (1969) to Embeth Davidtz in "The Gingerbread Man" (1998), Altman is fascinated by the beauty and power women are capable of, as well as by the potential for destructiveness that coexists with their sense of themselves as vulnerable. In "Nashville," Geraldine Chaplin is a wizard at archness, missing the main point repeatedly with great wit. In her first film, Blakley gives a performance that's ridged with emotion. When she isn't performing, her Barbara Jean, a reigning country queen, is just psychic flotsam and jetsam. When she does perform, all the bits and pieces come into sync. There may not be a real personality in Barbara Jean, but at least it all sometimes moves to the same rhythm. Barbara Harris, a jazzy stylist of instability, never registered in another film as memorably as she does here. Playing a daffy, miniskirted, bleached-blond hillbilly with fantasies of stardom, she's like a kitten on Quaaludes. When she does get her chance to sing, and she strews leftover flowers to the crowd, it's as though she's distributing bits of her ragamuffin heart.
It's eerie how accurately "Nashville" pointed the way to the future. Here is our coming attachment to the "outsider" candidate, and our tireless hunger for authenticity and sincerity; here's how feeling good about ourselves and griping about taxes came in the '80s to take precedence over everything else political. In the film, once the crisis has been reached, every relationship snaps back to its previous state; we're watching the country try to reaffirm its innocence. It rejects what it has seen of itself; the surface closes over again, like ice over a pond. This could almost be an anticipation of how, during the Reagan years, we acted out a manufactured version of normality and cheerfulness for ourselves.
Altman's 1970-1975 streak can be seen as an extension of American painting from the mid-'50s on, and of American writing of the '60s -- as an example of pop art. For a couple of decades after World War II, pop -- the teen-centered, Imperial America version of consumer culture -- seemed young, irreverent and disrespectful of tradition and stuffiness, as well as garish and horrifying. To many artists, it seemed a great subject, source and vehicle for art. Robert Rauschenberg, James Rosenquist, Norman Mailer, Tom Wolfe and Terry Southern, among many others, took on pop subjects and worked in pop forms, bringing sophistication and perspective to pop while borrowing back its pizazz and accessibility. In a movie such as "Major Dundee," Peckinpah dramatized his antagonistic relationship to pop with an abstract-expressionist fury. Altman was cooler, looser and more flexible -- Robert Frank as a happy cartoonist.
The outdoor concert occurs at the Parthenon, a giant replica of the Greek temple erected for Nashville's 1897 Centennial Exposition. (Originally constructed of wood and plaster, it was rebuilt in its present form in 1922.) The reporter Howard K. Smith does an essay on television about the candidate; the Goodyear blimp passes overhead flashing the candidate's slogan. It's a cloudy, milky day, but the colors are thick, broad and flat. We watch the stage being built, the traffic jam up and a line of black limos snake through town.
This getting-ready sequence seems straightforward, but it has a fated quality. (Even if you don't respond to it as I do, it's still a model of bringing strands together while keeping them all distinct.) I ran it over and over on my VCR, and I still can't explain why it has the poised yet deranging, hallucinogenic effect it does. When the black limos pull onto the green grass behind the Parthenon, we watch them circle from above, between massive lemon-cream pillars. As Blakley and Gibson swing into a song, we're above and behind them too. Then Blakley starts to sing about her parents, and we're watching her from close up and underneath. There's an immense flag fixed to the pillars behind her. When it billows out with the wind, you're reminded of a scene earlier in the film. It's at the airport; Blakley is returning from her convalescence to a city-sponsored welcome that's like a parade. There are bands, reporters, crowds and marching girls. For a few seconds the sound of the entire scene is drowned out by a taxiing jet with a big "American" sign on its side. The colossal scale of the joke is part of the humor -- it's one of the biggest damn jokes since Buster Keaton tumbled a train into a river in "The General."
Watching the earlier scene, you giggle. Here, when that flag billows out, you feel like you're going insane. Blakley's emotions surge, rise and crest. And amazingly, at that moment the sun -- the sun! -- comes out. The moment is so intense you don't know whether you're in ecstasy or whether you shouldn't don an aluminum-foil hat to shield yourself from so many vibrations. All that's on screen is a singer singing, yet -- if you respond to Altman as I do -- the inside of your skull feels as though it's being painted on by such "artists of the insane" as Christian Wolfi. The feeling is sinister and beautiful; you feel there's no turning back. Altman creates disordered, media-overload effects of the sort Thomas Pynchon is often said to create, and he does it without sacrificing aesthetic distance. (Pynchon always seems to me more interested in creating a nervous breakdown than in writing about one.) The center comes apart, and we've never felt freer. And we love our affliction.
3. The cinema of information
In the summer of 1975, I was a film student at NYU, and the day "Nashville" opened, I was among the first people in line at the Baronet. (Altman's 1971 "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" was the film that made me fall in love with movies.) Altman walked by with a few people, checking out the business. I ran after him and asked for an autograph. Feeling foolish, dizzy and thrilled, I gave him the only thing I had with me he could sign -- a copy, as it turned out, of Karel Reisz's book on film editing.
It was a cuckoo time. There was an intoxication about filmmaking and filmgoing -- a euphoria and a fever. For many people, an interest in movies and movie history provided a way into the arts and a framework for exploring them. Films like "Nashville," "The Conformist" and "The Godfather" were peak experiences that seemed to bring together all your interests in the arts -- high and low, visual, auditory and literary. A figure like Godard or Altman or Coppola opened up new directions and led you into discoveries not just in art but also in your life, in terms of sex, philosophy, love, fantasy and friendship. So these figures meant something to you personally. They transformed you; they made a difference in your sense of what was possible.